Our Pizzas
The Classics
These pizzas are classics for a reason. We sell more of these three flavors than any other - both as full pies and as slices. (❤️ - Best Seller, 🫑 - Vegetarian, 🌶️ - Spicy, 😎 - Uniquely Nico's)
Cheese
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with whole-milk mozzarella
Pepperoni
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with whole milk mozzarella and pepperoni. (Our top selling pizza)
Hawaiian
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with whole milk mozzarella, Canadian bacon, and pineapple (yes, pineapple goes on pizza)
Menu Pizzas
Try one of our tested and approved flavor combinations. Each of these has its own loyal following. Unless otherwise specified, each comes with whole milk mozzarella. Substitutions / change allowed. (❤️ - Best Seller, 🫑 - Vegetarian, 🌶️ - Spicy, 😎 - Uniquely Nico's)
Backyard BBQ
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with hamburger, crispy bacon, onions, and mozzarella and cheddar cheese, finished with smoky BBQ sauce
BBQ Chicken
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with grilled chicken, crispy bacon, onions, and sweet pineapple, finished with smoky BBQ sauce
Bunker Hill
Nico’s Sauce (an out-of-this-world, made-in-house, creamy vinaigrette) topped with thin-sliced grilled chicken and crispy bacon
Chicken Parmesan
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with breaded chicken and an extra helping of whole-milk mozzarella
Chicken Pesto
Creamy alfredo sauce and pesto sauce topped with grilled chicken, broccoli, fresh spinach, and garlic
CMA
Creamy alfredo sauce topped with grilled chicken and mushrooms
Cucina Paradiso
Garlic butter topped with grilled chicken, fresh spinach, finished with sliced almonds
Eye of the Tiger
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with grilled chicken, crispy bacon, roasted red peppers, finished with buffalo sauce
Fenway
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with sliced tomatoes, basil, and an extra helping of whole-milk mozzarella
Greek Royalty
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with sliced tomatoes, broccoli, black olives, and crumbled feta
Green Monster
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh spinach, onions, mushrooms, black olives, bell peppers, and pineapple, finished with sliced almonds
Italian Stallion
Topped with pepperoni, steak, fresh spinach, and garlic, no sauce
Margherita
Hearty house tomato sauce with fresh garlic, finished with basil
Mark Anthony
Crushed red peppers topped with breaded chicken, spinach, crispy bacon, and garlic
Meatza Chiena
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, canadian bacon, sausage, hamburger, and crispy bacon
Nico's Special
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers
North End
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with canadian bacon, mushrooms, and black olives
Primavera
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with broccoli, sliced tomatoes, onions, peppers, and mushrooms
Queen Margotte
Fragrant pesto topped with sliced tomatoes and spinach, finsihed with fresh basil
Spicy Hawaiian
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, pineapple, and green peppers
Strada di Roma
Creamy alfredo sauce topped with grilled chicken, fresh spinach, and artichokes
Three Cheese
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with cheddar, romano, and an extra helping of whole-milk mozzarella
Tonalli Special
Nico’s tomato sauce topped with grilled chicken, canadian bacon, and bacon finshed with buffalo sauce
Villanova
Creamy alfredo sauce topped with steak, bell peppers, onions, and mushrooms
Nico's Secret Pizza Menu
We are always testing new pizzas. These combinations have all made the cut. Try them to find your new favorite. Unless otherwise stated, all these come with Grande shredded, whole-milk mozzarella. (❤️ - Best Seller, 🫑 - Vegetarian, 🌶️ - Spicy, 😎 - Uniquely Nico's)
BAM
Creamy alfredo sauce topped with mushrooms and broccoli
BLT
Nico's sauce topped with tomatoes and bacon, and finished with fresh chopped lettuce
Carnivore
Nico's tomato sauce topped with steak, hamburger, meatballs, bacon, roasted red peppers, and extra sauce
Chicken Caprese
Fragrant pesto topped with chicken and bacon, and finished with fresh tomatoes and balsamic glze
CBR
Ranch dressing topped with chicken and crispy bacon
Dr Pepper-oni
Nico's tomato sauce topped with sandwich pepperoni, pepperoni, and cupping pepperoni
Fire
Nico's tomato sauce and pesto sauce topped with crushed red pepper, pepperoni, hot sausage, onion, garlic, and jalapenos
Garden Gnome
Nico's sauce topped with tomatoes, mushrooms, and black olives
King Benjamin
Pesto sauce topped with crushed red pepper, spinach, tomatoes, chicken, and crispy bacon
Lewinski
Nico's tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, chicken, bacon, and jalapenos, finished with teriyaki, BBQ and buffalo sauce (yes, all three)
Links
Nico's tomato sauce topped with salami, pepperoni, and sausage
MRS
Nico's tomato sauce topped with spinach, meatballs, and ricotta
Old North Church
Nico's tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, meatballs, mushrooms, and black olives
Pizza Bianca
Creamy alfredo sauce topped with fresh garlic and olive oil
POP
Nico's tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, olives, and pineapple
Porker
Nico's tomato sauce topped with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and bacon
Premier League
Nico's tomato sauce topped with a double portion of our regular pepperoni, and cupping pepperoni
Stirfry
Teriyaki sauce topped with chicken, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and carrots
Super Hawaiian
Nico's tomato sauce topped with Canadian bacon, bacon, peppers, pineapple, and cupping pepperoni
Sweaty Hawaiian
Nico's tomato sauce topped with crushed red pepper, pepperoni, pineapple, and jalapeno
Sweet and Sassy
Nico's tomato sauce topped with pepperoni and hot sausage, finished with honey drizzle
Ultimate Cheeseburger
Nico's pizza sauce topped with meatballs, crispy bacon, onion, and cheddar, and finished with fresh tomatoes